Fall and dark lipsticks just go together. I love most dark lippies, but plum and/or purple are a big favorite. I have quite a few already, so I'm trying not to buy anymore, but most of mine are matte. When I saw that MAC's Brooke Candy collection had an Amplified dark purple named Which Witch?, I had to try it. I love it. It gives me the dark, vampy look that I love but it's creamy so it goes on smoothly and isn't so obvious about my lip lines.
These pics are lipstick only, no foundation, mascara, or anything. Imagine how good it will look with brows pencilled in and a little eye make-up!
Which Witch is still available on MAC's web site, btw.